Youth Sports: What Do Kids Really Gain?

There’s no ironclad proof that sports build character. The results of a meta-analysis on the connection between athletics and character development make that clear: “Forty years of research, conducted by more than 20 researchers studying tens of thousands of athletes and non- athletes from youth, high schools, collegiate and Olympic levels, simply does not support the notion of sport as a character-building activity, particularly as it applies to sportsmanship behaviors and moral reasoning ability.”

It’s true that coaches can build cooperative team cultures and reinforce useful habits among players. “But that doesn’t mean they necessarily creep over to class, school, occupation, or family,” explained Jay Coakley, the country’s preeminent youth sports sociologist. Furthermore, athletic teams are not the only place for kids to learn how to work together, and it’s impossible to determine which particular experience makes a person highly disciplined, say, or genuinely collaborative. “I played sports all the way through college, and beyond,” he said, “but I did all kinds of other things, too, that have made me who I am.” There’s simply insufficient data to tease out the effect of youth sports on a person’s character vis-à-vis other activities and experiences that also shape development.

But that’s not to say that kids don’t learn from youth sports, or that coaches have no lasting impact on how children mature. Richard Weissbourd, a child and family therapist who runs the Making Caring Common project at Harvard, says that kids make discoveries through sports, but what they absorb is entirely dependent on the context. If a coach degrades players, makes competition too central to the experience, leaves kids out, tolerates backtalk to the referees, and mismanages parents, then kids will pick up destructive lessons. “Sports can be harmful to kids in these conditions,” he said. On the other hand, if the coach is fair and respectful to the team and referees; if she helps kids empathize with players on both teams; if she enables kids to handle loss, and to be grateful, and to respect her opponents, then yes—sports can build character. In short: it all depends.

In the absence of evidence, there are theories and testimonials posited by philosophers, child development experts, and ordinary adults who insist that athletics sculpted their lives. “My high school sports experiences shaped me into a functioning adult,” Maggie Lynch, now twenty-four, explained in an email. Aidan Connly, a recent college graduate who played high school football and lacrosse, said, “I learned to never quit and to ignore the noise.” Jacqui Young, twenty-seven, said playing volleyball, softball, and basketball as a teenager taught her how to work with others, to appreciate her responsibility to the collective. (Group projects in the classroom resonated in a different way: “They made me feel more put-upon than anything,” she said.)

Memories may not be controlled experiments, but the volume and intensity of such reports is striking. Indeed, it seems that every adult who played youth sports growing up can instantly resurrect a story from the playing field or team bus that had an impact. Kids can grow from sports in other ways, too. Competitive athletic environments compel them to engage with their own and others’ powerful feelings. Before long, they learn to manage the anger, sadness, embarrassment, and joy that playing evokes. If the sports environment is healthy, kids can also learn how to control their aggression.

In games, after all, one team or individual is pitted against another, and during that competition the goal is to defeat the other—aggressively, if need be. But once the contest is over, everyone reverts back to human beings again, maybe even friends, and the aggression has to be shut down. “It’s hard to imagine a more powerful deterrent to violating another human being,” Weissbourd wrote, “than recognizing that our hostile feelings toward another person are a kind of fiction, manufactured by a game, and have nothing to do with him or her at all — that we irrationally invent enemies.”

With the right leadership, sports also can invite other moral virtues, including appreciation for an opponent’s skill, toleration for a weaker player’s mistakes, and respect for an imperfect referee. This kind of “demanding morality,” Weissbourd wrote, builds empathy: children learn that their emotions, no matter how passionate, are not paramount—that others’ feelings and experiences are equally valid.

Philosophy professor Drew Hyland argues that serious engagement in sports also can trigger two profound interior developments: “the experience of deep, passionate commitment and self-knowledge.” Hyland drew on his own time playing basketball to share how deeply it had affected him. “There was no experience in my scholastic or college education that led me to more self-knowledge than my basketball experience, no course or classroom in which I learned more about my capacities, my limitations, where I was willing to compromise, and where I would take my stand.”

We ferry our kids to the field for the same reason our parents did: because we believe sports build character. But the evidence is lacking, and the milieu in which kids now play is inclined to do the opposite. Coakley believes that the way youth sports have changed over the past twenty years undermines character development. “Sports have gotten more cutthroat and competitive among kids and parents,” he said. “Some kids survive the system because they’ve joined other activities. They’ve made it in spite of sports and become a pretty good twenty-three-year-old.”

To the extent that there’s consensus on sport’s contribution to character, then, it appears to be this: what kids glean from athletics depends entirely on a shifting and tangled array of variables. Community values, parental attitudes toward sports, the coaches’ manner and methods, the child’s own temperament and training, and countless other intangibles determine what kids learn from athletics. Sports themselves are empty vessels, imbued with the meanings we attach to them.

Allison Green
Boston Tutoring Services